The shop refuses to repair, replace or refund — who helps?
Across the EU you have a two-year legal guarantee: if a product is faulty, the seller (not the manufacturer) must repair or replace it, and refund if that fails. Put the complaint in writing to the seller first. If they refuse, Altroconsumo (altroconsumo.it) is the consumer body in Italy that advises and mediates. For a seller in another EU country, Centro Europeo Consumatori Italia (06 44238090) handles it for free. The last step is Conciliazione paritetica / Giudice di pace — the dispute board or small-claims route.
Free answers, kept free by members
FFCheck is a small team in Amsterdam: 32 countries, every answer free and with its sources. No ad networks, no affiliate links; sponsors are labelled and never change an answer.
Members pay for keeping every page checked and current, for new countries and topics, and for the letters.
What you get as a member
- Every FFCheck Letter included: make one whenever you need it, no payment each time
- Each letter ready to send: print-ready PDF and email text, with your next step and the final reminder
- Sign in without a password, cancel any time; it runs to the end of the month you paid for
- Thanks to you, FFCheck stays free for everyone: members pay for checking every page and adding new countries
Facts from this page's own sources · a small team in Amsterdam · no ad networks · delete everything any time
🗣️ What to say
"I bought [product] on [date], order [number]. It is faulty: [what]. Under the legal guarantee I ask you to repair or replace it within 14 days, or refund €…. Please confirm in writing."
🪜 Step by step
- Write to the sellerE-mail with the order number, the fault, photos, and a 14-day deadline. The seller is responsible, even if they point you to the manufacturer.
- Know your rightTwo years legal guarantee EU-wide; in the first year the fault is presumed to have existed at purchase. Online purchases can also be returned within 14 days for any reason.
- Ask AltroconsumoThey confirm what you can demand and often write to the seller for you.
- Cross-border? Centro Europeo Consumatori ItaliaThe European Consumer Centre handles disputes with sellers in another EU country, Norway or Iceland, free of charge.
- Escalate to Conciliazione paritetica / Giudice di paceA dispute resolution body or small-claims court; decisions are usually binding on the seller.
📇 All contacts
❓ Frequently asked
Repair, replacement or money back — who chooses?
You ask for repair or replacement first; the seller may pick the cheaper one if it is not a burden for you. If that fails or takes too long, you can ask for a price reduction or a full refund.
The seller says the warranty expired
The manufacturer's warranty is a bonus. The legal guarantee is two years from delivery and cannot be shortened by the shop.
Can I return something I just do not like?
Online and door-to-door purchases: yes, 14 days, no reason needed. In a physical shop: only if the shop's own policy allows it.
📎 Sources
🔎 Common searches
Recognise your own search? The answer above covers all of these.
- “shop refuses refund Italy”
- “consumer rights faulty product Italy”
- “legal guarantee 2 years”
- “complaint against webshop”
- “consumer authority Italy”
🧭 Is this still correct?
We check this information carefully, but phone numbers, websites and rules change — and sometimes we get something wrong. Spotted a mistake or a change? Let us know below.
This form only corrects this page. It does not go to the police or any authority, and nobody will act on what you write. To report something, use the contacts on this page. In an emergency, call the emergency number. Do not write names, number plates or other people's details here.
⚠️ Readers report that something here may have changed — we are checking it.
✅ Thank you — this keeps the page up to date for everyone.