The garage overcharged or did not fix my car — who helps?
A car repair in Italy is a contract for work (contratto d'opera) or a works contract (appalto): without your authorisation the garage may not change the agreed work, and under an appalto the authorisation must be proven in writing (Civil Code art. 1659). For a defective repair you can ask for the defect to be removed at the garage's cost or for a price cut (art. 1668): report it in writing at once, at the latest within 8 days of discovery (art. 2226; 60 days under an appalto, art. 1667). Until its claim is paid, the garage may keep the car (art. 2756): if the amount is disputed, pay under written reservation and claim the difference back. Altroconsumo (altroconsumo.it) is the first stop for advice and the complaint; Camera di commercio — servizio di mediazione (unioncamere.gov.it) offers mediation, which is mandatory before a court claim for contracts for work; Giudice di pace (e-justice.europa.eu) decides if needed.
Garage dispute? Let's put it in writing.
- Your letter today, free to preview
- The answer date worked out for you
- A final reminder and your next step, in the same pack
We write, you send, the next step is ready.
Letter €4.99 once · FFCheck One €4.99 a month · Prices include VAT.
See all options
Facts from this page's own sources · a small team in Amsterdam · no ad networks · delete everything any time
🗣️ What to say
"Invoice [number] for [repair] on [date]. [The amount exceeds the quote by [x] without my consent / the fault is not fixed]. I ask you to [correct the invoice / redo the repair] within 14 days. Otherwise I refer the case to Camera di commercio — servizio di mediazione."
🪜 Step by step
- Get the quote in writingBefore any work, next time. This time: what was agreed by phone, message, or the job sheet you signed.
- Do not pay the disputed partUntil its claim is paid the garage may keep the car (Civil Code art. 2756). Pay what was quoted and dispute the rest in writing; if it will not release the car, pay in full under written reservation and claim the difference back.
- Second opinionAnother garage's written finding on the "repair" is the best evidence.
- Complain to AltroconsumoGet advice on your rights and put the complaint on record; send copies, never the originals.
- Mediation: Camera di commercio — servizio di mediazioneA mediator helps you and the garage reach an agreement; for contracts for work (contratto d'opera) mediation is mandatory before a court claim (Legislative Decree 28/2010, art. 5). Bring the job sheet, the quote, the invoice, photos and another garage's written finding.
📇 All contacts
❓ Frequently asked
The garage keeps my car until I pay
In most countries a garage may keep the car until the repair bill is paid. Pay under written protest, take the car and claim back the part you dispute.
They did "necessary" work without calling me
Without your authorisation the garage may not change the agreed work; under an appalto the authorisation must be proven in writing (Civil Code art. 1659). If the work really was needed to do the repair properly and you cannot agree, a judge sets the changes and the price (art. 1660). Ask for the replaced parts.
A used car broke down a week after purchase
That is a faulty-goods question: the dealer is liable for defects present at delivery under the legal guarantee, and for used cars some countries allow a shorter period by contract. Different page (faulty goods), same bodies.
📎 Sources
- Altroconsumo →
- Camera di commercio — servizio di mediazione →
- Giudice di pace →
- Motorizzazione civile (UMC) / ACI PRA →
- Codice civile, art. 1659 — Variazioni concordate →
- Codice civile, artt. 1667–1668 — Difformità e vizi dell'opera →
- Codice civile, art. 2226 — Contratto d'opera: difformità e vizi →
- Codice civile, art. 2756 — Privilegio e diritto di ritenzione →
- D.lgs. 28/2010, art. 5 — Mediazione obbligatoria →
- Unioncamere — Mediazione delle Camere di commercio →
🔎 Common searches
Recognise your own search? The answer above covers all of these.
- “garage overcharged complaint Italy”
- “car repair not fixed rights”
- “motor trade dispute body Italy”
- “garage holding car until payment”
- “repair beyond quote consent”
🧭 Is this still correct?
We check this information carefully, but phone numbers, websites and rules change — and sometimes we get something wrong. Spotted a mistake or a change? Let us know below.
This form only corrects this page. It does not go to the police or any authority, and nobody will act on what you write. To report something, use the contacts on this page. In an emergency, call the emergency number. Do not write names, number plates or other people's details here.
⚠️ Readers report that something here may have changed — we are checking it.
✅ Thank you — this keeps the page up to date for everyone.